I know that this has been a hot button topic. Words like ‘rape culture’, ‘no means no’, and ‘consent counts’ all have been used alot lately. How a woman is dressed and how she presents herself seems to be a neon sign for some that say “I need to take that and to hell with what they say. They obviously want it.”
In Kink community the lines are blurred continuously. We are a subculture where the focus is sex. We dress to impress and titillate 9 times out of 10. Our get togethers are events that are to teach about better ways to please our partners, to sell items to get to that level and give us the environments in play spaces to do it. It is a subculture that is based on the endorphin high of sexual pleasure. So where can and is the line drawn?
I bring this up after dealing with some unpleasant conversations over the weekend. A female friend of mine contacting me about how a known predator of “newbies” was going to be on panels about sex, kink, kink& religion and polyamory at a sci-fi convention. Personally I had alot of anger. I thought he was blacklisted enough to not get onto any more panels or teach at events, but as one person who I spoke to said, “He was using a name he usually doesn’t use so I didn’t realize it was the same guy.
Why should it bother me? Because what he does is not hearsay. I have experienced it first hand and as someone who has watched them systematically wait for the changing of the guard when it comes to those in charge so he can enter in undetected has disgusted me. Why have I never spoken up? Why have I not cried rape or unsafe player? It’s a fair question and sadly the answer is because in the past it has not made a difference. I can hear some of my close friends on this who are venomous in the concept of consent cry out “bullshit”, but let me explain.
In my almost 20 years in the kink community I have have a total of 3 incidences that were stalking, abuse and/or rape. 2 where I have gone to higher powers looking for help or changes and in both cases I was shut down. One was a case of stalking and being made uncomfortable at organization based play parties and when I went to the board of the organization with 4 other girls who had the same problem the answer was “we’ll keep an eye on him.” Needless to say when a few years past and he ran for the board of that same organization I was angry beyond belief. Since the organization is a “volunteer” based organization and he was a “valuable volunteer” they were not going to ban him or limit his access to anything the organization was doing.
A few years later I kept company with a man who invited me to his home. I accepted because I had people who I had respected vouch for him. We talked, We had a drink, he kissed me, we went to his room and then it went all wrong. I didn’t ask to be punched in the chest or slapped in the face, I didn’t ask to have his fingers jammed inside me to the point where I screamed from the intense pain, said ow and no. I tried to get away and he just held me in place. I fought and the more I fought the hard he hit me. I finally just stopped fighting and knew he would stop. Every time I tried to leave the bed while he slept he pulled me in tight. All I wanted to do was escape and finally when he was in a deep sleep at 5 in the morning I could. I was mortified and ashamed. I could barely face my primary at the time with what happened. I went to people who knew this beast and was faced with the kind of questions and comments that I was shocked to hear from them.
- “well you have a rep for liking it rough.”
- “why didn’t you safe word?”
- “You can’t possibly be talking about THAT guy.”
- “maybe you gave him the impression you wanted that”
- “I don’t believe you.”
- “Well he’s never done anything bad to me”
I was sick. To this day it has affected how I view certain higher ups in this community and how we are all so willing to believe that someone is not a monster simply because it didn’t happen to them. This individual still teaches and there are those that still raise his flag. This man is the reason why I do not attend Dark Odyssey events of any kind. If they are comfortable enough to have him there to teach then I want nothing to do with them and since he is protected by powerful people in the community I fear nothing will change.
That experience colored my lack of willingness to say anything about this third one. I should have known better. I had watched him stalk and go after many women all of who were young and new. Maybe I thought that since I was neither young or new there would be no issues. I was wrong. Again the problem was this. I was staying at his home, I consented to him curling up with me in bed. I had told him my limits in advance and I watched them all fall away. I was brutalized, he fucked me without my consent, I could not escape. I could not say no because his fingers were in my mouth pulling my cheeks away to pain and I couldn’t get anything but sounds out. My tears and crying only excited him more. When it was over I got dressed and said I had a meeting I needed to go to. The meeting was hours away but I needed to get out of there. Once outside I threw up. When I did confront him on what happened his excuse was that he had “lost control” and that he “thought I liked that sort of thing”.
I only spoke out about him to those close to me. I didn’t think going public was going to be helpful especially since I had people start giving me the same kind of lines as before. I did finally have some believe me and I did also find others who had the same story as I. It finally came to a head when I was teaching at the same event as this individual and I basically told the head of presenters to keep him away from me. When I told him why he was immediately concerned. I was relieved when I saw that he was not going to be teaching again anytime soon. Then I started getting calls about this current Scifi convention. When I made some inquiries about it I was told that their were people who were aware and that they had a “watch team” created to keep an eye on him.
Keep an eye on him? This means to me that you know full well in advance that you have let a dangerous individual into an event. An event that is not even a kink event but an event that is a scifi con that has kink classes. That you know his reputation and yet you still let him in and speak as if he has some validity to his knowledge sets a horrible president for the future.
So what am I getting at with all of this?
How is this not just a rant?
We constantly talk about consent but sometimes that concept is not as clear as black and white. Sometimes it’s not a case of “No” meaning don’t touch me. I think alot of people consider consent meaning Yes = touch me and No= don’t touch me. When it can mean Yes= kiss me and No= don’t fuck me. Yes= you can hold me down and No= you can’t punch or slap me. Don’t interact with me expecting me to do with you what I do with my play partner of 6 years. What I do with say my Sir is different from what I do with my play partner in Chicago and that is different from my play partner in Boston or NY. Just because you’ve seen me take it hard doesn’t mean you can take me hard.
It’s to the point where this community sometimes scares me. That it protects too many monsters simply because they don’t want to admit that they made a mistake in supporting someone for too long. What they don’t understand is that their silence does more damage than saying “I was wrong.”